European Stock Exchange

    European Stock Exchange

    The Bridge Between Crowdfunding and Regulation

    The European Stock Exchange - It's Time to Think Different

    It’s a Long Way to European Equity Crowdfunding Regulation

    Insights from the European Crowdfunding Convention 2015

    The European Crowdfunding Network (ECN) has been holding its 4th Convention in Paris. The main topic of the first day was the Capital Markets Union and its implications for crowdfunding.

    The European equity funding gap

    The Capital Markets Union (CMU) is a plan of the European Commission to modernize and harmonize the regulation of capital markets in order to increase the size of capital markets in Europe and thereby foster the economy and create jobs.

    As it stands, Europe’s equity markets are less than half the size of US capital marketswhile the two economies are roughly of the same size. European financial systems have traditionally been bank- centric, which may explain why they have more problems recovering from the banking crisis. There needs to be more balance. It is expected that the European economy would be more crisis resistant if capital markets played a greater role.

    In addition to the general issue of underdeveloped capital markets, small and medium-sized companies (SMEs) have even more limited access to equity funding because existing capital markets are designed, serviced and regulated with larger firms in mind.

    For this reason, the European commission has proposed an action plan that includes promoting innovative forms of business financing such as equity crowdfunding and crowdlending.

    Local crowdfunding regulations do not help the EU regulation process

    Steven Maijoor, Chair, European Securities and Markets Authority (ESMA) expressed his regrets that local governments of the European Union such as France, the UK and Spain are publishing localcrowdfunding regulation that will ultimately be very difficult to harmonize.

    He argued that equity crowdfunding can already be regulated within the existing capital market regulation framework, MIFID. He underlined the many benefits of the European regulation in terms of customer protection. Not only does it contributes to fighting fraud but, most importantly, it creates transferable securities and provides the basis for secondary markets that are an essential part of customer protection.

    “The ability to trade private securities on a secondary market is a classic investor protection issue, in a MIFID world, securities are transferrable securities”

    Steven Maijoor, Chair, ESMA

    In addition, Investment Services Directive (ISD) enables crowdfunding platforms to operate across all European countries using the so-called passportthat enables any investment services firm regulated in one country to serve investors and issuers from other European countries.

    The ESMA is looking very closely into crowdfunding but it has no intention to propose a specific passport for crowdfunding platforms because existing regulations for investment services, securities trading, and banking already provide all the ingredients for “passporting” crowdfunding.

    Why national regulators continue to regulate away

    EU regulation may, in principle, provide crowdfunding platforms with all regulatory ingredients necessary to create market trust and operate across borders, but it does not work in practice.

    The first reason is that even where European regulations in the form of a European Directive exists, local governments may interpret it in different ways. Local authorities also respond to local demand by SMEs and crowdfunding platforms by providing exemptions to European capital market regulations and innovating at its margins. This is not about to change.

    “Whereas we agree that convergence is the goal, the CMU should not be an attempt to create a centralized market. There should be room for national preferences.”

    François-Régis Benois, Autorité des Marchés Financiers, Director of the Division of Listed Companies

    As an example, where regulated by local regulation, the simplified prospectuses required for equity crowdfunding may vary in length from 2 pages in Austria to 3 pages in Germany, 5 pages in Italy and 10 to 12 pages in France. In the same vein, the upper limit of funds that can be raised with a simplified prospectus vary from €100,000 euros according to EU law to €1 million euros in France, €1.5 million in Finland, €2.5 million in the Netherlands and €5 million in Italy and the UK.

    “If a UK company wants to raise funds from a Finnish investor on a German equity crowdfunding platform, it is quite unclear which of these limits will apply.

    Tero Weckroth, Chairman, Invesdor.”

    This state of affairs is not specific to crowdfunding. It is characteristic of the complexity of operating in the fragmented European market where, according to the principle of subsidiarity, local regulators often believe that they should exert their precedence over EU regulators.

    For SMEs, the cost of EU regulation is out of whack with its benefits

    The second and equally important reason why EU regulation is not easy to implement is the cost. Where capital markets regulation could apply to crowdfunding, its cost is out of reach for both SME issuers and platforms.

    For example the cost of listing, servicing and clearing securities on traditional exchanges, and, to some extent, due to regulation, on alternative exchanges as well (MTFs), is very high –thus barring SMEs and crowdfunding platforms from offering a secondary market for their shares.

    Even if the CMU intends to lower some requirements such as the prospectus requirement, the entire capital markets’ ecosystem is currently geared towards servicing larger issuers and publically traded companies. Thus, beyond regulation there is a need to create a more cost-effective ecosystem in line with the cost efficiencies of crowdfunding marketplaces.

    In the end, the resolution of the tension between EU regulation and national regulations might not come from issuing more EU regulations but from dealing with existing ones:

    “Many believe that rescue will come from more EU regulation, but they will be disappointed because a crowdfunding-specific EU regulation would only add more layers on top of local regulations. What is needed is agreement on exemptions from EU regulations such as MIFID.”

    Tanja Aschenbeck-Florange, Partner Osborne Clarke, Germany.

    European investors’ culture is changing

    Regulators are concerned with customer protection, and in particular with protecting retail investors.

    Traditionally, in the bank-dominated European market, consumers have been encouraged to place their savings in risk-free deposit accounts or in packaged instruments with low risk and a lot of fees attached to them. Distrust with established finance, low-interest rates and the need to fund their retirements now lead many retail investors to look for better return and get more involved in capital markets.

    This creates is a need for consumer education as much as for customer protection.

    “We’ll see how the CMU will cut the Georgian of finding a balance between customer protection and simplifying SMEs’ access to capital”

    Christian Zenz, Deputy Head of Division – Austrian Federal Ministry of Science, Research and Economy.

    Therese Torris is an entrepreneur and consultant in eFinance and eCommerce based in Paris. She has covered crowdfunding and P2P lending since the early days when Zopa was created in the United Kingdom. She was a director of research and consulting at Gartner Group Europe, Senior VP at Forrester Research and Content VP at Twenga. She publishes a French personal finance blog, Le Blog Finance Prat


    Featured Posts

    KPMG - The Pulse of Fintech Q4, 2106

    China: WeiyangX Fintech Review

    The Cambridge Centre for Alternative Finance, Monash Business School & Tsinghua University, Join

    From cancer treatment to restaurant openings - how crowdfunding turned us all into investors.

    Ram Ahluwalia of PeerIQ Shares the Future of Online Lending

    How Crowdfunding Took On Private Equity And Won

    Brexit slowdown? There's been a 'large-scale drop' in UK startup funding for the first t

    Innovate Finance Report on VC Investment into Fintech: Up Globally, Down in the UK

    Brexit bites UK fintech as funding falls by 34% in 2016

    Germany: Investment Crowdfunding Grew by 39% in 2016

    {"items":["5fda4b180abcba0017a07b13","5fda4b180abcba0017a07b1b","5fda4b180abcba0017a07b1a","5fda4b180abcba0017a07b19","5fda4b180abcba0017a07b1c","5fda4b180abcba0017a07b17","5fda4b180abcba0017a07b16","5fda4b180abcba0017a07b18","5fda4b180abcba0017a07b15","5fda4b180abcba0017a07b14"],"styles":{"galleryType":"Strips","groupSize":1,"showArrows":true,"cubeImages":true,"cubeType":"fill","cubeRatio":"100%/100%","isVertical":false,"gallerySize":30,"collageDensity":0.8,"groupTypes":"1","oneRow":true,"imageMargin":0,"galleryMargin":0,"scatter":0,"rotatingScatter":"","chooseBestGroup":true,"smartCrop":false,"hasThumbnails":false,"enableScroll":true,"isGrid":false,"isSlider":false,"isColumns":false,"isSlideshow":true,"cropOnlyFill":false,"fixedColumns":1,"enableInfiniteScroll":true,"isRTL":false,"minItemSize":120,"rotatingGroupTypes":"","rotatingCropRatios":"","columnWidths":"","gallerySliderImageRatio":1.7777777777777777,"numberOfImagesPerRow":3,"numberOfImagesPerCol":1,"groupsPerStrip":0,"borderRadius":0,"boxShadow":0,"gridStyle":0,"mobilePanorama":false,"placeGroupsLtr":false,"viewMode":"preview","thumbnailSpacings":4,"galleryThumbnailsAlignment":"bottom","isMasonry":false,"isAutoSlideshow":true,"slideshowLoop":false,"autoSlideshowInterval":3,"bottomInfoHeight":0,"titlePlacement":"SHOW_ON_HOVER","galleryTextAlign":"center","scrollSnap":true,"itemClick":"nothing","fullscreen":true,"videoPlay":"hover","scrollAnimation":"NO_EFFECT","slideAnimation":"SCROLL","scrollDirection":1,"scrollDuration":400,"overlayAnimation":"FADE_IN","arrowsPosition":0,"arrowsSize":18,"watermarkOpacity":40,"watermarkSize":40,"useWatermark":true,"watermarkDock":{"top":"auto","left":"auto","right":0,"bottom":0,"transform":"translate3d(0,0,0)"},"loadMoreAmount":"all","defaultShowInfoExpand":1,"allowLinkExpand":true,"expandInfoPosition":0,"allowFullscreenExpand":true,"fullscreenLoop":false,"galleryAlignExpand":"left","addToCartBorderWidth":1,"addToCartButtonText":"","slideshowInfoSize":160,"playButtonForAutoSlideShow":false,"allowSlideshowCounter":false,"hoveringBehaviour":"NEVER_SHOW","thumbnailSize":120,"magicLayoutSeed":1,"imageHoverAnimation":"NO_EFFECT","imagePlacementAnimation":"NO_EFFECT","calculateTextBoxWidthMode":"PERCENT","textBoxHeight":0,"textBoxWidth":200,"textBoxWidthPercent":50,"textImageSpace":10,"textBoxBorderRadius":0,"textBoxBorderWidth":0,"loadMoreButtonText":"","loadMoreButtonBorderWidth":1,"loadMoreButtonBorderRadius":0,"imageInfoType":"ATTACHED_BACKGROUND","itemBorderWidth":0,"itemBorderRadius":0,"itemEnableShadow":false,"itemShadowBlur":20,"itemShadowDirection":135,"itemShadowSize":10,"imageLoadingMode":"BLUR","expandAnimation":"NO_EFFECT","imageQuality":90,"usmToggle":false,"usm_a":0,"usm_r":0,"usm_t":0,"videoSound":false,"videoSpeed":"1","videoLoop":true,"jsonStyleParams":"","gallerySizeType":"px","gallerySizePx":226,"allowTitle":true,"allowContextMenu":true,"textsHorizontalPadding":-30,"showVideoPlayButton":true,"galleryLayout":5,"targetItemSize":226,"selectedLayout":"5|bottom|1|fill|false|1|true","layoutsVersion":2,"selectedLayoutV2":5,"isSlideshowFont":true,"externalInfoHeight":0,"externalInfoWidth":0},"container":{"width":226,"height":288,"galleryWidth":226,"galleryHeight":127,"scrollBase":0}}
    Recent Posts

    KPMG - The Pulse of Fintech Q4, 2106

    China: WeiyangX Fintech Review

    The Cambridge Centre for Alternative Finance, Monash Business School & Tsinghua University, Join

    From cancer treatment to restaurant openings - how crowdfunding turned us all into investors.

    Ram Ahluwalia of PeerIQ Shares the Future of Online Lending

    How Crowdfunding Took On Private Equity And Won

    Brexit slowdown? There's been a 'large-scale drop' in UK startup funding for the first t

    Innovate Finance Report on VC Investment into Fintech: Up Globally, Down in the UK

    Brexit bites UK fintech as funding falls by 34% in 2016

    Germany: Investment Crowdfunding Grew by 39% in 2016

    {"items":["5fda4b180abcba0017a07b13","5fda4b180abcba0017a07b1b","5fda4b180abcba0017a07b1a","5fda4b180abcba0017a07b19","5fda4b180abcba0017a07b1c","5fda4b180abcba0017a07b17","5fda4b180abcba0017a07b16","5fda4b180abcba0017a07b18","5fda4b180abcba0017a07b15","5fda4b180abcba0017a07b14"],"styles":{"galleryType":"Columns","groupSize":1,"showArrows":true,"cubeImages":true,"cubeType":"max","cubeRatio":1.7777777777777777,"isVertical":true,"gallerySize":30,"collageAmount":0,"collageDensity":0,"groupTypes":"1","oneRow":false,"imageMargin":22,"galleryMargin":0,"scatter":0,"rotatingScatter":"","chooseBestGroup":true,"smartCrop":false,"hasThumbnails":false,"enableScroll":true,"isGrid":true,"isSlider":false,"isColumns":false,"isSlideshow":false,"cropOnlyFill":false,"fixedColumns":0,"enableInfiniteScroll":true,"isRTL":false,"minItemSize":50,"rotatingGroupTypes":"","rotatingCropRatios":"","columnWidths":"","gallerySliderImageRatio":1.7777777777777777,"numberOfImagesPerRow":3,"numberOfImagesPerCol":1,"groupsPerStrip":0,"borderRadius":0,"boxShadow":0,"gridStyle":0,"mobilePanorama":false,"placeGroupsLtr":false,"viewMode":"preview","thumbnailSpacings":4,"galleryThumbnailsAlignment":"bottom","isMasonry":false,"isAutoSlideshow":false,"slideshowLoop":false,"autoSlideshowInterval":4,"bottomInfoHeight":0,"titlePlacement":["SHOW_ON_THE_RIGHT","SHOW_BELOW"],"galleryTextAlign":"center","scrollSnap":false,"itemClick":"nothing","fullscreen":true,"videoPlay":"hover","scrollAnimation":"NO_EFFECT","slideAnimation":"SCROLL","scrollDirection":0,"scrollDuration":400,"overlayAnimation":"FADE_IN","arrowsPosition":0,"arrowsSize":23,"watermarkOpacity":40,"watermarkSize":40,"useWatermark":true,"watermarkDock":{"top":"auto","left":"auto","right":0,"bottom":0,"transform":"translate3d(0,0,0)"},"loadMoreAmount":"all","defaultShowInfoExpand":1,"allowLinkExpand":true,"expandInfoPosition":0,"allowFullscreenExpand":true,"fullscreenLoop":false,"galleryAlignExpand":"left","addToCartBorderWidth":1,"addToCartButtonText":"","slideshowInfoSize":200,"playButtonForAutoSlideShow":false,"allowSlideshowCounter":false,"hoveringBehaviour":"NEVER_SHOW","thumbnailSize":120,"magicLayoutSeed":1,"imageHoverAnimation":"NO_EFFECT","imagePlacementAnimation":"NO_EFFECT","calculateTextBoxWidthMode":"PERCENT","textBoxHeight":60,"textBoxWidth":200,"textBoxWidthPercent":75,"textImageSpace":10,"textBoxBorderRadius":0,"textBoxBorderWidth":0,"loadMoreButtonText":"","loadMoreButtonBorderWidth":1,"loadMoreButtonBorderRadius":0,"imageInfoType":"ATTACHED_BACKGROUND","itemBorderWidth":0,"itemBorderRadius":0,"itemEnableShadow":false,"itemShadowBlur":20,"itemShadowDirection":135,"itemShadowSize":10,"imageLoadingMode":"BLUR","expandAnimation":"NO_EFFECT","imageQuality":90,"usmToggle":false,"usm_a":0,"usm_r":0,"usm_t":0,"videoSound":false,"videoSpeed":"1","videoLoop":true,"jsonStyleParams":"","gallerySizeType":"px","gallerySizePx":1000,"allowTitle":true,"allowContextMenu":true,"textsHorizontalPadding":-30,"itemBorderColor":{"themeName":"color_12","value":"rgba(78,78,78,0)"},"showVideoPlayButton":true,"galleryLayout":2,"calculateTextBoxHeightMode":"MANUAL","targetItemSize":1000,"selectedLayout":"2|bottom|1|max|true|0|true","layoutsVersion":2,"selectedLayoutV2":2,"isSlideshowFont":true,"externalInfoHeight":60,"externalInfoWidth":0.75},"container":{"width":220,"galleryWidth":242,"galleryHeight":0,"scrollBase":0,"height":null}}
    • February 2017 (11)
    • January 2017 (2)
    • November 2016 (10)
    • October 2016 (4)
    • August 2016 (1)
    • July 2016 (5)
    • June 2016 (8)
    • May 2016 (10)
    • April 2016 (19)
    • March 2016 (19)
    • February 2016 (11)
    • January 2016 (12)
    • December 2015 (1)
    • November 2015 (9)
    • October 2015 (10)
    • September 2015 (12)
    • August 2015 (19)
    • July 2015 (6)
    • June 2015 (3)
    • May 2015 (2)
    • March 2015 (2)
    • February 2015 (1)
    • January 2015 (1)
    • August 2014 (13)
    • June 2014 (1)
    • April 2014 (1)
    • March 2014 (1)
    • May 2013 (2)
    Archive
    Follow Us
    • Facebook Basic Square
    • Twitter Basic Square
    • Google+ Basic Square
    • Home

    • Listings

    • How it Works

    • News

    • Guide to ESE

    • Apply for Listing

    • Investor Registration

    • Contact

    • T&C

    • Privacy Policy

    • Regulation

    • Company Login

    • Investor Login

    • Help

    • More

      Investor Login
      Company Login

       

      © 2015 European Stock Exchange Group

       

      ESE is not regulated by any investment authority and does not broker and or arrange any transactions that require regulation. We do not trade stock or offer any advice whatsoever. Whilst we take reasonable care to ensure that information on the site is clear, fair and not misleading we do not provide any guarantee, warranty or representation as to its accuracy or completeness. The content of this website does not constitute or form part of any offer by ESE to enter into any contract or agreement nor is it a solicitation to buy or sell any investment.  This website should not be regarded as an offer or solicitation to conduct investment business, as defined by the UK Financial Services and Markets Act 2000 in any jurisdiction other than the United Kingdom. Investors who are resident in or citizens of countries other than the United Kingdom may be subject to local restrictions. This will also apply to all other jurisdictions where similar restrictions exist.  Please note that the value of investments and the income from them may fluctuate and you may not receive back the amount originally invested. Past performance is no guarantee of future performance. Currency movements may also affect the value of investments. The investments and investment services referred to on this website may not be suitable for all investors. If you are unsure as to whether the investments described in this site are suitable for you we recommend you seek professional advice from a financial adviser. ESE may not provide financial, investment or other professional advice to retail clients. Nothing on this site should be interpreted as constituting financial advice. ESE is a platform and does not arrange or raise capital for any companies listed on the platform.

      YOU SHOULD OBTAIN RELEVANT PROFESSIONAL ADVICE SPECIFIC TO YOUR CIRCUMSTANCES BEFORE MAKING ANY INVESTMENT DECISION.

      List with Us

       

      Register as an Investor

       

      Collaborate with Us

       

      Our Charter

       

      Jobs

       

      Reports

      Tools

       

      Partners

       

      The Power of PR and News

       

      Information Packs and Fee Paying

       

      Report a fault with one of our pages

       

      Features 

       

      Social 

      News

       

      The Power of Research

       

      History of Stock Exchanges

       

      Investor Certificates

       

      Investor Seats on ESE

       

      The ESE Fund

       

      Reverse Private Equity

       

      ISA Allowances 2014/2015

       

      Investor Portfolio

       

      Ticker Tape Rules 

       

      Verified by ESE

       

      V

       

      Contact

       

      Privacy Policy

       

      General Terms and Conditions

       

      Terms for Listing Companies

       

      Regulation                           *